Do you really need an LLC before buying your first rental property? This is one of the most common questions I get, and today, I’m breaking down the pros and cons — when you actually need one, and how to set it up the smart and affordable way. The truth is, sometimes you do, and sometimes you don’t. Getting it wrong can cost you time, money, and stress. So let’s clear it up.
I’m Melissa Nash, and I have built a 7-figure rental portfolio from my couch. Today, I’m walking through one of the biggest investor questions I get: LLC or no LLC?
——————————————————————————–
FREE copy of The Ultimate Guide to Passive Real Estate Investing.
If you missed our last episode, be sure to listen to TBT: Ask Marco – Can I Invest with Low Income and Poor Credit?
Our team of Investment Counselors has much more inventory available than what you see on our website. Contact us today for more deals.
Here’s the deal — I’m just going to shoot it to you straight. I think LLCs are a good idea. They help provide protection and help you run your investment like a business. But do you need one before you buy your first property? Well, it depends on the type of loan you’re using.
If you’re using a conventional loan — think standard Freddie or Fannie loans — you cannot close directly in an LLC. The property must be titled to your personal name, and lenders will run your credit and qualify you personally. However, after closing, you can do a quit claim deed to transfer the property into an LLC. You can do this any time after closing, whether it’s a day, two years, three years, or four years later. There are different reasons why you may or may not want to move that property into an LLC, but for the most part, LLCs are for asset protection.
Now, the second type of loan you might be considering for a single-family investment property is called a DSCR loan — which stands for Debt Service Coverage Ratio. The rules are different here: you’re actually required to close in an LLC. That means you need to set up your LLC before you close. The lenders will still check your credit, but the title and deed will be in the name of the LLC.
Let me share how I personally do this. First, I want to say that I am not a CPA or an attorney. I’m just sharing what I’ve done personally and what I’ve seen other investors do. Always seek out your own legal and financial counsel. This is not professional advice. Everyone’s situation is different, and everyone will tell you something different.
Some attorneys will set up your LLCs and charge you upwards of $10,000. Yes, you heard that right. There are large packages out there with high price tags, and you have to decide what’s best for you. The way I do it is a little different. For asset protection and privacy, I open my LLCs in Wyoming. It’s also really affordable — I can open one for under $200. I live in California, and I would never, ever open an LLC here. They’re expensive to set up, expensive to renew, and just not worth it for me. Wyoming, on the other hand, is business-friendly, private, fast, and cheap. I can get an LLC and the incorporation documents in less than 24 hours. I love it.
I use a company exclusively for all of my LLCs — they’re absolutely wonderful. Once you enter your information, they do all the work. They’ll email you your incorporation documents, and if you do it in Wyoming, it’s lightning fast. After that, go to the IRS website and get a free EIN number. You can also pay a company to do it for you, but honestly, it’s so easy and fast, you might as well just do it yourself.
Once you have your incorporation documents and your EIN, go open a business bank account. Most likely, you’ll have to go in person — I haven’t found a bank that will do it online. Whether you’re at Bank of America, Wells Fargo, or wherever you bank, just take in your documents and they’ll set it up for you. Be sure to use the name and address of your LLC. This business bank account will be used exclusively for your property income and expenses. It’s a huge step that keeps you organized and separates your business from your personal finances — something the IRS and your CPA will thank you for.
I also recommend setting up a second savings account just for reserves. That way, when repairs or vacancies happen (and they will), you’re ready. At some point, you’ll have to pay for something — whether it’s maintenance or a vacancy. You don’t know when or how much, but you should always be prepared. That’s why I suggest doing this all at once — set up the savings account while you’re setting everything else up.
Let me give you a real-world example. I bought a property in Memphis, Tennessee using a conventional loan. The loan was in my name, the title was in my name, and after closing, I went to the title company and had them do a quit claim deed into my Wyoming LLC. It cost me around $300 — super simple, super easy.
Now, another deal I did recently involved a DSCR loan. When I put the property under contract, I gave my lender the name of my Wyoming LLC, which is how I was closing on the loan. But right before closing, they said, “Hey, we need to see your Arkansas LLC.” I had completely forgotten about that! When closing with a DSCR loan — at least with my lender and many others — they want you to have an LLC in the state where the property is located, or you can do a foreign registration. In my case, the foreign registration in Arkansas was going to take too long, so I quickly set up a new Arkansas LLC and listed my Wyoming LLC as the owner. That gave me a bit of extra protection, and everything closed smoothly. No issues, just a slight delay. I used the same company I always use, and now all my LLCs are in one place online. If I ever need to look anything up, I can just log in and find it. Super convenient.
So, depending on the loan type, you can either set up the LLC upfront or do it after closing. My CPA once told me something that I think is worth repeating: LLCs are not about tax benefits — they’re about asset protection and organization. An LLC gives you separation: your rental business in one bucket, your personal finances in another. It keeps everything clean, organized, and professional.
That’s why I recommend starting an LLC early. Even if you don’t think you need it for your first loan, it’s still a good idea to have one just for setting up a business bank account. From day one, it puts you in the right mindset — this is a business. And that mindset is crucial. Every decision you make shouldn’t be personal, it should be business.
So, do you need an LLC before buying your first property? It depends. If you’re using a conventional loan, no — you don’t need one, but you can transfer the property into an LLC later. If you’re using a DSCR loan, yes — you’ll need one before closing, and you might need one in the state where you’re buying. Either way, I highly recommend treating your rentals like a business and keeping everything separate.
Again, this is just my experience. If you’ve been thinking about jumping in, now is the time to book that free strategy call. Whatever you need — if you want more information, just hit that button to connect with us. The links are in the show notes below, or you can go to www.noradarealestate.com. We can’t wait to help you and chat about your real estate goals. Let’s take some action and get started. Can’t wait to hear from you — see you on the next episode. Bye-bye.
And a big thank you to Melissa for today’s episode and for sharing her experiences. If you found this helpful, be sure to subscribe so you never miss future discussions. We’ve got plenty more value-packed content coming your way, and we appreciate you being here. Thanks for listening, and we’ll see you on the next one.
—————————————————————————————————
Download your FREE copy of: The Ultimate Guide to Passive Real Estate Investing
See our available Turnkey Cash-Flow Rental Properties